Blogs

Essential Oil vs Fragrance Oil Candles: What's the Difference?

Stāndle Aromatic
A small glass bottle of fragrance oil

Essential oil candles use plant oils; fragrance oil candles use a blend made for wax. How they differ in scent, consistency and safety, and how to read the label.

Short answer: an essential oil candle is scented with oils taken directly from plants. A fragrance oil candle is scented with a blend made for the purpose, which can include aroma molecules, natural isolates and sometimes essential oils too. Neither is automatically better or safer. Fragrance oils usually throw scent more reliably in wax; essential oils appeal to people who want plant-derived ingredients. What matters most is what the label tells you.

The two, side by side

Essential oil Fragrance oil
What it is Aromatic oil extracted from a plant, usually by steam distillation or, for citrus, by pressing the peel A blend formulated for a scent, which can combine aroma molecules, natural isolates and essential oils
Range of scents Limited to plants that yield an oil Almost any scent, including notes no plant gives up as an oil
In a lit candle Can fade quickly; many oils are light and volatile Usually built to stay stable in heat and fill a room evenly
Consistency Varies with the harvest The same from batch to batch
On the label "Scented with essential oils" or "100% essential oils" "Fragrance oil", ideally with "phthalate-free" and the notes by name

Why essential oils often fade in a candle

A candle releases scent from its melt pool. Many essential oils, especially citrus and other bright top notes, are light and evaporate quickly. In the jar they smell vivid; once the wax is hot, they can be gone well before the end of the burn. That is why a candle described as pure essential oil can smell strong cold and faint lit.

Fragrance oils are usually formulated with that heat in mind. A perfumer can balance light and heavy materials so the scent opens, holds and lingers across a whole burn. If a candle you already own smells weak once lit, the oil is only one possible cause: see how to make a candle smell stronger.

"Natural" is not the same as "safer"

It is easy to assume that an essential oil candle is the safer choice. It is not that simple. Essential oils are concentrated plant chemicals, and some of them are a real concern around pets. Eucalyptus, tea tree and citrus oils are among those most often flagged for cats; more on that in are soy candles safe for cats?

Fragrance oils have their own question to ask: phthalates. These are plasticizers some fragrance oils use to help scent bind to wax, and a phthalate-free fragrance oil is formulated without them. Any scented candle releases some compounds when it burns, whichever oil it uses, so ventilation and a trimmed wick matter in both cases. The longer version: are scented candles safe?

How to read a candle label

  1. Check the wording. "Made with essential oils" can mean a small amount of essential oil inside a fragrance oil blend. "100% essential oils" is a stronger claim.
  2. Look for "phthalate-free" on any candle that uses fragrance oil.
  3. Look for the notes by name. Lavender, sandalwood and oakmoss tell you what you will smell. "Fresh" and "cozy" do not.
  4. Check the wax and the wick. The oil is one part of the candle. The wax and the wick decide how cleanly it burns. More on that: what makes a candle non-toxic.

What Stāndle uses

Stāndle candles use phthalate-free fragrance oil, not pure essential oils, at an 8% fragrance load in 100% soy wax with a lead-free cotton wick. Each scent is built in three layers, and every note is listed by name:

  • Lavendure 21: black currant, lemon and orange; lavender, eucalyptus leaf and fir needle; amber and oakmoss.
  • Sandalure 18: cinnamon, nutmeg and black pepper; Geranium Bourbon and clove; sandalwood, aged patchouli and Madagascar vanilla.

Lavendure 21 soy candle by Stāndle with lavender, eucalyptus, fir, citrus and oakmoss

Each candle is 300 g, burns for about 50 hours and is poured in Los Angeles into a hand-cast concrete vessel. How the fragrance layers are put together: our fragrance.

Comparing a diffuser with a candle rather than one candle oil with another? That is a different question: essential oils vs scented candles.

FAQ

What is the difference between essential oil and fragrance oil candles?

Essential oil candles are scented with oils extracted from plants, usually by steam distillation or, for citrus, by pressing the peel. Fragrance oil candles are scented with a blend made for the purpose, which can combine aroma molecules, natural isolates and sometimes essential oils. Fragrance oils are usually formulated to hold and release scent in wax; essential oils are not.

Do essential oil candles smell as strong as fragrance oil candles?

Often not. Many essential oils are light and evaporate quickly, so they can smell clear in the jar and fade once the candle is lit. Fragrance oils are usually built to carry in a melted wax pool, which is why most scented candles use them.

Are essential oil candles safer than fragrance oil candles?

Not automatically. Natural does not mean harmless, and some essential oils, such as eucalyptus, tea tree and citrus oils, are a concern around cats. What matters more is what the brand discloses: the wax, whether the fragrance is phthalate-free, the wick, and the notes by name.

Why do most candle brands use fragrance oil?

Because it is designed for wax. A fragrance oil can be built to stay stable in heat, to throw evenly across a room and to smell the same from batch to batch, and it can create scents that have no essential oil at all, such as many fruit, wood and amber notes.

Do Stāndle candles use essential oils or fragrance oil?

Stāndle candles use phthalate-free fragrance oil at an 8% fragrance load in 100% soy wax. Every note is listed by name on the product page, so you can see what each candle is built from before you buy.

Related reading